Rare Susan B. Anthony Portrait Found in Hidden Photo Studio Is Going Up for Auction

Susan B. Anthony Portrait Found in Attic

When attorney David Whitcomb purchased a building in Upstate New York for his law firm, he never could have imagined the treasures that he'd find inside. Tucked into a small attic that Whitcomb didn't know existed when he bought the building was the entire studio of photographer James E. Hale. Active during the late-19th and early 20th centuries, Hale was a prominent local photographer whose client roster included suffragette Susan B. Anthony.

The discovery is all the more incredible because the sellers of the building had no idea that the attic existed above the third-floor ceiling. And, in fact, neither did the owners prior to them. Whitcomb and a friend only made the discovery while examining water damage on the third level. After peeking his head inside the space and seeing a huge quantity of items stacked up, including gold frames, Whitcomb called in a friend who could help him make sense of what he was looking at. “We quickly realized all the material was photographs and photography related and repeatedly saw the name J.E. Hale, on photos, boxes, shipping containers, and even found a stack of his mail from approximately the fall of 1916,” Whitcomb tells My Modern Met. “The organization of the materials was confusing, while it looked like certain pieces had been neatly stacked and organized others were almost thrown here and there.”

Then, as they were meticulously going through the material, they came upon something truly special—a side portrait of Susan B. Anthony. And this wasn't just any portrait, but an official portrait that even ended up in the Library of Congress‘ collection. And, as if that find wasn't extraordinary enough, Whitcomb even found pieces of the original glass negative.

James E. Hale Portrait Studio Discovered in Attic

“I was on my hands and knees picking something up when I noticed some large pieces of glass on the ground, picked one up and put my flashlight behind it and immediately stopped,” he shared. “What I was looking at was the center part of the Susan B. Anthony portrait, the flag pin she's wearing in the photo, and part of her dress.  I could not believe I was holding this glass plate negative, and we quickly found other large portions of the negative.  Unfortunately, we did not find all of it, but we have a significant portion of it and it's just amazing to think that negative was in the room when that image was taken, and that's her burned into the glass.”

After a year, Whitcomb has finally cataloged his treasures, which he calls the Hale Collection. Aside from the famous portrait, there are many photographs of the local area, portraits of his clients, as well as camera equipment. Some of the extra special finds also include hand-painted backdrops that Hale would have had his clients sit in front of during their portrait sessions.

Taking advantage of his location just outside of Rochester, Whitcomb was able to get professionals from Eastman Kodak involved in restoring some of the photos. He's also worked with local history museums and photo shops to have about 50 of the glass negatives printed.

Early 20th Century Glass Negative

Now that everything has been cataloged, it's time for these items to find a home. On September 18 at 3 p.m. EST, there will be a live auction of all the materials—including the Susan B. Anthony portrait. All items are also viewable on Invaluable, where bids are already being accepted.

“The auction will allow everyone to see the collection online and for the materials to find a home within the genre the buyers prefer,” says Whitcomb. “There are different angles to this collection, from the arts, photography, photographic history, women's history, and the suffragist movement, to that little piece of all of us that wants to ‘find treasure' hidden somewhere, so it's very exciting.”

Attorney David Whitcomb discovered a hidden attic in the building he'd purchased.

James E. Hale Portrait Studio Discovered in Attic

Within the attic were materials from the studio of early 20th-century photographer James E. Hale.

Among the finds was an incredibly rare portrait of Susan B. Anthony.

Susan B. Anthony Portrait Found in Attic

Susan B. Anthony Portrait Found in Attic

The studio was filled with other treasures as well, like a field camera and photo backdrops.

Now everything is up for auction on September 18, 2021.

My Modern Met granted permission to feature photos by David Whitcomb.

Related Articles:

Woman Discovers Over 30,000 Secret Photos Left Behind by Her Mother

A $4 Thrift Store Painting Is Actually by David Bowie and Will Sell for Thousands

Vintage Photos of Everyday Life in 1950s New York Discovered in Attic 50 Years Later

Photographer Finds 120-Year-Old Cat Photos After Developing Film Found in a Time Capsule

Jessica Stewart

Jessica Stewart is a Contributing Writer and Digital Media Specialist for My Modern Met, as well as a curator and art historian. Since 2020, she is also one of the co-hosts of the My Modern Met Top Artist Podcast. She earned her MA in Renaissance Studies from University College London and now lives in Rome, Italy. She cultivated expertise in street art which led to the purchase of her photographic archive by the Treccani Italian Encyclopedia in 2014. When she’s not spending time with her three dogs, she also manages the studio of a successful street artist. In 2013, she authored the book 'Street Art Stories Roma' and most recently contributed to 'Crossroads: A Glimpse Into the Life of Alice Pasquini'. You can follow her adventures online at @romephotoblog.
Become a
My Modern Met Member
As a member, you'll join us in our effort to support the arts.
Become a Member
Explore member benefits

Sponsored Content